Unattainable Eggnog Pie (Simple One-Bowl Vacation Dessert)

In case you take pleasure in eggnog throughout the holidays, this Unattainable Eggnog Pie is like Christmas in a pie. The middle is tender and custardy, and the highest turns golden, making it style like a mixture of basic custard pie and creamy vacation pudding. Nutmeg and cinnamon add a comfortable taste with out being too robust, and a little bit of whipped cream on prime makes it even higher.

Slice of impossible eggnog pie topped with a swirl of whipped cream and a dusting of ground nutmeg, served on a black plate with the full pie and a glass of eggnog in the background; festive holiday dessert featuring a creamy custard filling and golden brown crust.

What I really like most about this pie is how easy it’s. You simply whisk every part in a single bowl and pour it into the pie plate. There isn’t a crust to roll out and no layers to fret about. It’s the form of dessert you may make on a busy December day and nonetheless deliver one thing do-it-yourself and nostalgic to the desk.

stacie’s notice

Over time, my household and buddies began calling me the “Queen of Unattainable Pies,” and I don’t thoughts in any respect. I’ve a number of favorites that everybody appears ahead to, just like the basic Unattainable Pie and my savory Unattainable Cheeseburger Pie, which at all times goes shortly. Each time I deliver a pie, somebody normally asks whether it is one other Unattainable one, and more often than not, it’s.

I’m at all times pondering of latest variations as a result of these pies are really easy. I like that you just simply combine every part in a single bowl and pour it into the pie plate. There isn’t a rolling, no chilling, and no worrying a few crust.

Substances

The total printable recipe card with measurements and directions is discovered on the backside of the submit.

Sugar: Common white sugar works finest right here and offers the pie that basic Unattainable Pie sweetness. In case your eggnog is further candy, you may reduce the sugar again barely with out affecting the feel.
Bisquick baking combine: That is the magic ingredient that helps the pie set and kind its personal tender crust because it bakes. Ensure it’s contemporary so the pie rises and units correctly.
Salt: Only a small quantity balances the sweetness and retains the pie from tasting flat.
Eggs: Use massive eggs at room temperature in order that they mix easily and assist create that custardy heart.
Eggnog: Full fats eggnog offers the richest taste and creamiest texture. In case your eggnog could be very thick, give it a fast stir earlier than measuring.
Unsalted butter: Soften the butter and let it cool barely earlier than including it so it doesn’t scramble the eggs.
Vanilla extract: A great high quality vanilla actually shines in a easy recipe like this and boosts the eggnog taste.
Floor nutmeg: Freshly grated nutmeg offers one of the best taste, however pre floor works simply effective. A bit further on prime provides a festive end.
Floor cinnamon: This provides heat and depth with out overpowering the eggnog. Stick with a light-weight hand so the pie nonetheless tastes like eggnog first.

How one can Make Unattainable Eggnog Pie

Step One: Preheat the oven to 350°F. Grease a 9-inch pie plate.
Step Two: In a big mixing bowl, whisk collectively sugar, Bisquick, salt, and spices.
Step Three: Add eggs, eggnog, melted butter, and vanilla. Whisk collectively.
Step 4: Pour into the ready pie plate.
Step 5: Bake for 45 to 55 minutes, or till the middle is simply set and a knife inserted within the center comes out clear.
Step Six: Cool utterly earlier than slicing. Serve with whipped cream and a sprinkle of nutmeg.

Collage of mixing ingredients in a bowl.

Store Really useful Merchandise!

From cookware to helpful kitchen devices, take a look at all my favourite merchandise used to create on a regular basis recipes!

Variations and Substitutions

Use do-it-yourself eggnog: In case you have do-it-yourself eggnog available, it really works fantastically on this pie. Simply be certain that it’s nicely combined earlier than measuring.
Swap the spices: Not a cinnamon fan? Depart it out and follow nutmeg solely, or add a pinch of cloves or allspice for a barely totally different vacation taste.
Add coconut: Stir in ½ to ¾ cup sweetened shredded coconut or coconut flakes for a delicate coconut taste and a little bit further texture.
Add a splash of rum taste: For a basic eggnog twist with out alcohol, add a small splash of rum extract. A bit goes a good distance.
Serve it your manner: This pie is nice by itself, however it additionally pairs nicely with whipped cream, a drizzle of caramel sauce, or perhaps a dusting of powdered sugar proper earlier than serving.

Golden brown custard pie with a creamy center in a glass dish, set on a wooden table with festive red berries nearby.

Storage Directions

Fridge: Cowl the pie tightly with plastic wrap or retailer slices in an hermetic container within the fridge for as much as 4 days. The feel really will get a little bit firmer and even higher after it has had time to relax.
Freezer: You possibly can freeze this pie for as much as 2 months. Wrap the entire pie or particular person slices tightly in plastic wrap, then add a layer of foil. Thaw in a single day within the fridge earlier than serving.
Make Forward Tip: This can be a nice make-ahead dessert. Bake it the day earlier than, let it cool utterly, then refrigerate till you’re able to serve. Add whipped cream and a sprinkle of nutmeg simply earlier than serving for one of the best presentation.

Slice of creamy custard pie with golden crust, topped with whipped cream and sprinkled with nutmeg on a black plate.

Recipe Ideas and Tips

Let the pie cool utterly earlier than slicing. It’ll proceed to set because it cools and also you’ll get cleaner slices.
Place the pie plate on a baking sheet earlier than placing it within the oven. This makes it simpler to switch and catches any spills.
In case you don’t have Bisquick, you may make a fast do-it-yourself model. Combine ½ cup all-purpose flour, ¾ teaspoon baking powder, a pinch of salt, and 1 tablespoon chilly butter. Stir or reduce it in till evenly mixed, then use it rather than the Bisquick.
Examine the pie a couple of minutes earlier than the tip of the bake time. The middle needs to be simply set and nonetheless have a slight jiggle.
If the highest is browning too shortly, loosely cowl it with foil for the final 10 to fifteen minutes.

Eggnog Desserts

Comply with me on Instagram @simplystacieblog, Fb at Merely Stacie, TikTok @simplystacierecipes or Pinterest at @simplystacie and let me know the way you appreciated this recipe and my different recipes.