Fish Fertilizer vs Miracle-Gro

Is fish fertilizer higher than an artificial fertilizer like Miracle-Gro?

Should you learn the promoting for fish fertilizer, you may conclude that it’s going to develop a lot better vegetation, however those self same merchandise don’t present you any information to help the claims. The place is the proof?

I made a decision to run my very own check to see if fish fertilizer grows greater tomato vegetation.

Key Takeaways

Fish fertilizer didn’t develop statistically higher vegetation.
The additional value of fish fertilizer can’t be justified based mostly on development.

This publish makes use of affiliate hyperlinks

A lot of individuals use fish fertilizer, pondering that it’s a higher product. I went in search of some analysis that validates this reality, and was very shocked that I couldn’t discover a single research that examined a business product.

I reached out to Neptune’s Harvest and had a gathering with Ann Molloy. She confirmed that they didn’t have any scientific research to point out their product is best than artificial fertilizer. I additionally reached out to Alaska Fish Fertilizer and a Canadian producer referred to as Acadie; neither had research supporting their claims.

The businesses make quite a few claims, however all they should validate them is anecdotal information, which we all know is just not “definitely worth the display screen it’s displayed on“.

So, I made a decision to do some testing myself.

My Experiment Setup

I began a bunch of tomato ‘Roma’ seeds utilizing my customary dishevelled technique. It’s a good way to begin all seeds, and it makes it straightforward to know you might be sowing germinated seed.

plastic bag pus paper towel with germinated tomato seeds in it — Tomato seeds germinating utilizing the Saggy Methodology, July 23, supply: Robert Pavlis

Twenty 3.5″ sq. pots have been full of my customary ProMix HP potting media. A germinated seed was planted in every pot. In a few days, they have been displaying above the soil line.

Building Natural Ponds book, by Robert Pavlis

The pots have been put below a MetryGrow 100W LED develop gentle. It produced 8,000 lux (PPFD of 120) at soil degree, set in veg mode, for 16 hours, at 50%. The sunshine quantity was fairly fixed throughout all pots, however to make sure that all vegetation acquired equal lighting, they have been shifted round each couple of days, so every plant spent a while below the middle of the sunshine.

The vegetation have been break up into 2 teams on the time of planting to remove any bias on my half. One-half acquired fish fertilizer and the opposite acquired Miracle-Gro; each mixtures have been made as much as a 100 ppm nitrogen degree, as calculated by the PPM Fertilizer Calculator.

Fish Fertilizer: Acadie hydrolyzed fish fertilizer, made by Acti-Sol, was used, with an NPK of 2-4-0.5.

Artificial Fertilizer: Miracle-Gro 24-8-16 water-soluble fertilizer.

Pots have been watered with fertilizer answer, as wanted, beginning as quickly because the germinated seed was added. ProMix does include some fertilizer, however the producer recommends vegetation be fertilized quickly after planting.

Plant Development

Vegetation grew nicely through the experiment. At in regards to the midway mark, each teams of leaves did present some edema, which was most likely brought on by an excessive amount of water on the roots. Leaves grew higher within the second half of the experiment.

Tray of 20 tomato seedlings with first true leaf forming — Rising seedlings on August 2

Tray of 20 tomato seedlings with 2 leaves each — Rising seedlings on August 11

Tray of 20 tomato seedlings with 3 to 4 leaves each — Seedlings on August 25, simply earlier than measurements have been completed

On the finish of the experiment, on August 25, every seedling was minimize off on the soil degree. The size between the bottom and the uppermost department was measured. Because the higher leaves curved to various levels, this appeared like a extra constant technique to measure top.

In talking to Neptune’s Harvest, they identified that top won’t fluctuate an excessive amount of on this experiment, however that the thickness of the stem needs to be extra pronounced with fish fertilizer. They gave no cause for this, and I don’t see why this needs to be the case. Nonetheless, I made a decision to additionally measure the stem thickness on the base, simply above soil degree.

Experimental Knowledge

Listed below are the outcomes evaluating Fish to Miracle-Gro fertilizer.

Peak and width information for tomato seedlings rising below fish fertilizer or Miracle-Gro, supply: Backyard Fundamentals

The width of the stems was the identical for each fertilizers. Vegetation fertilized with fish fertilizer have been barely greater, however the top distinction is just not statistically vital at a 5% degree.

Is Fish Fertilizer Higher Than a Artificial Fertilizer?

Based mostly on this experiment, there isn’t a vital distinction in development between the 2 fertilizers.

Fish fertilizer additionally has some “robust” negatives.

Odor. When combined and used recent, fish hydrolysate fertilizer doesn’t have a powerful odor. However as soon as it sits for a few days, it reeks.
Excessive value. Acadie fish fertilizer is 29 occasions dearer than Miracle-Gro, for a similar quantity of nitrogen. Neptune’s Harvest is 60 occasions dearer, and Alaska Fish Fertilizer is 25 occasions dearer than Miracle-Gro (costs are based mostly on Canadian sources).
Comfort. Artificial fertilizer may be made up and used as wanted. Producers advocate that fish fertilizer be diluted recent every time it’s required, principally to maintain the scent down.
Appropriate NPK ratio. Hydrolyzed fish fertilizer has an NPK of 2-4-0.5. Emulsified fish fertilizer has an NPK of 5-1-1. The Miracle-Gro fertilizer has the best NPK ratio for vegetation of 3-1-2.
Harming the Atmosphere. Some kinds of fish fertilizer are harming the setting by harvesting recent fish from the ocean; Alaska is an instance. Acadie and Neptune’s Harvest are extra accountable and use leftover fish waste.

The one plus for fish fertilizer is that it’s “natural”. I’ve appeared into this intimately in Is Fish Fertilizer Higher Than Compost?

Vegetation can’t actually use natural vitamins till they’re decomposed into non-organic vitamins. Some declare that the amino acids and nutritional vitamins in fish fertilizer add advantages. Plant roots can certainly take in amino acids, and entry to them ought to enable a plant to develop higher, however there appears to be little scientific proof that such natural sources work for classy vegetation. If in case you have such references, please add them to the feedback.

I can’t see any cause for utilizing fish fertilizer. I’ll stick with artificial fertilizer.